Essiac and Flor-Essence in cancer: more faith than fact.
July 13, 2009
History tells us of nurse Renée Caisse’s discovery, promotion, and subsequent investigation, that an unproved native North American herbal mixture has been used by patients for prevention or treatment of serious conditions such as cancer. Essiac is a herbal mixture – a complementary or alternative medicine, or CAM – that has been said to be formulated by an Ojiwan healer to “to purify the body and put it back in balance with the great spirit.” (1) and it’s recipe obtained by Caisse from a woman who claimed it cured her breast cancer (1).
In 1938, the Cancer Commission, established under the Cancer Remedies Act of Ontario, lead an investigation after growing concerns and questions about the use of Essiac. (2) Commission members concluded that there was limited evidence for the mixture’s effectiveness and were concerned about Caisse’s unwillingness to divulge Essiac’s composition. (2)
In fact, Caisse has reported to have used Essiac as a tea and administered one ingredient intravenously in her clinic to hundreds of patients for over 40 years. (1,3) Caisse reportedly worked on a formulation with physicians, namely with Dr. Charles Brusch, in order to modify the formula and to arrive at a final oral product (1). Both eventually sold rights in 1977 of the formulation to a Toronto based corporation, Resperin co. Limited (4). The following year, the Department of National Health and Welfare of Canada allowed Resperin to conduct studies on Essiac’s safety and effectiveness, but withdrew its permission four years later because the corporation was not proceeding with the studies as planned (1,5).
A second product, Flor-Essence (Flora Manufacturing and Distributing Ltd), contains the original 4 herbs in Essiac but with 4 additional ingredients, which are supposedly based on a formulation developed by Caisse and Brusch. (1,3,5,6). These products are available for purchase online and at health food stores. Essiac is available through Health Canada’s emergency release program. Purported use of Essiac and FlorEssence include treatment of cancer, quality of life, cancer-related mortality, chronic GI diseases (Ulcerative and inflammatory conditions), reduction in pain, increase in appetite, strengthening the immune system, treatment of HIV and diabetes. (1,3,5)
Since CAM (specifically vitamin-herbals) use in cancer patients is quite common (7) and especially since 1 in 7 (14.8%) Canadian breast cancer patients have reported to use Essiac (8), this article will review Essiac and Flor-Essence and their purported use in cancer treatment, prevention and quality of life.
Formulation and Mechanism(s) of Action(s)
Although good manufacturing practices are reportedly followed and dosage information is available (4), Currently, Essiac does not have a natural product number (NPN) that certifies the product’s standardisation of active ingredients (AI), nor has the FDA or Health Canada evaluated any health claim related to this product.
Today, Essiac products are manufactured and distributed by Essiac Canada International (ECI), who’s products contain the original 4 herb mixture formulation (4). These ingredients include:
-Arctium lappa L. (burdock root),
-Rheum palmatum L. (Turkish rhubarb),
-Rumex acetosella L. (sheep sorrel) and
-Ulmus fulva or U. rubra Muhl (the inner bark of slippery elm) (1,3,4)
Recommended at twice daily dosage for 12 week duration treatment of capsules, powder or tonic with price ranging from 200 to over 350 (CD|USD) dollars (4).
Flor-Essence contains the same 4 ingredients as Essiac, but with 4 additional ingredients, including:
-Nasturtium officinale R. Br (watercress),
-Cnicus benedictus L. (blessed thistle),
-Trifolium pratense L. (red clover) and
-Laminaria digitata Lmx. (kelp) (1,3,6)
Essiac’s mechanism(s) of action and Pharmacology
A few preliminary in vitro trials have suggested various physiological activities of Essiac or Flor-Essence and include antiproliferative, immunomodulatory, fibrinolysis inhibition and antioxidant activity (AA, BB,CC). One study did note an inhibition of mice-derived prostate cancerous cell lines by Essiac (CC), while another noted antiproliferative activity in a human breast cell line (DD). However, these results conflict with unpublished studies conducted by The Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center (EE) (which are reviewed here (FF)), and a controlled (paclitaxel as comparator) in vitro study on prostate cancer cell lines (GG). In another study, Flor-Essence and Essiac has been shown to stimulate breast cancer cell lines, both through estrogen-dependant and estrogen-independent mechanisms. (HH)
Because these studies are mostly preliminary and conflicting, we cannot postulate a coherent mechanism of action of active ingredients for treatment of human diseases. Little, if anything, is known about Essiac’s or Flor-Essence’s administration, distribution, metabolism or elimination (3).
Since these two CAM products contain multiple ingredients , it is important consider evidence about the herbal mixture products (Essiac or FlorEssence) instead of looking at studies on the seperate ingredients (ie: Slippery Elm, Red Clover) since this would make it very hard to assess the added effects in the body.
Clinical evidence in Humans
To date, there exists no randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) published – in peer-reviewed journals or otherwise – studying Essiac or Flor-Essence in the treatment or prevention of any cancer. Most human evidence on the mixture consist of subjective surveys (i.e: patients said they “felt better”) (II,JJ,KK) or case series which have resulted in inconclusive results on cancer mortality (FF). A retrospective cohort study involving 510 women with diagnosed breast cancer found that Essiac does not improve quality of life, nor does it improve mood states (LL).
Adverse Effects and Safety
Since no RCTs exist in humans, side effects (SE) of Essiac or Flor-Essence have not been adequately studied. Anaphylaxis (severe allergy), hyponatremia (low sodium in blood), nausea, vomiting, fatigue and diarrhea has been reported (3,NN). Furthermore, individual components of the mixtures have been reported to cause allergic dermatitis and laxative effects (1). Potential drug interactions theoretically could be of concern since it has been shown that Essiac, in vitro, can inhibit liver enzymes (CYP1A2, 2C19) (AA) and interact with an experimental chemotherapeutic agent (MM). Theoretical contraindications include children, pregnancy, renal and hepatic insufficiency (00).
There is a hypothetical risk of major bleeds due to the potential anti-inflammatory or blood thinning effects of Essiac/Flor-Essence. Patients on blood thinners should avoid avoid these two products and include people taking such drugs as (including but not restricted to): salisylic acide (ASA, Aspirin, Entrophen, Novasen), clopidogrel (Plavix), dipyridamol (Aggrenox), warfarin (Coumadin) and heparin-like injections.
Again, most of the evidence for safety comes from surveys taken by current or former cancer patients where they would report side-effects. Even if a particular this survey (JJ) showed 7% of patients reported “ill- effects” attributed to Flor-Essence, surveys typically misrepresents actual medical ouctomes; they are not adequate to really know if a particular side effect is really caused by a drug or natural health product (NHP). In other words, because surveys do not prove that a reported SE happens more oftenly with a NHP than in adummy pill (aka: placebo), we cannot accurately say that it does.
Conclusions and Recommendations
An important safety issue concerning any alternative medicine in cancer is the possibility of delayed conventional treatment. Certain cancers develop rapidly, so forestalling medical treatment in order to try Essiac, or any other CAM, to prevent the disease from growing or returning should never be attempted without medical supervision. Cancer is a serious disease that necessitates proper care by medical doctors and specialists (ie: Oncologist), and good physician-patient communication in order to receive quality health care.
Neither Essiac or Flor-Essence has any convincing evidence – or even promising – about it’s role in cancer management. Considering these facts; using an expensive treatment, duration of 12 weeks, mild digestive systems SE, some rare but serious SE (ie: anaphylaxis) and absolutely no reliable human data (not one RCTs on human cancer outcomes); the use of these two mixtures in prevention, treatment or cancer-related complication (i.e: mood, quality of life) have very limited role in cancer care.
This reviewer does aknowledge the issue of compassionate care in situations where patients are in terminal phase, or who have failed therapy or otherwise used all medical treatments or procedures to no avail. Situations like these are indeed complex and should always be directed under medical supervision and agreed upon after a good discussion between the patient and physician.
Kaegi (1) concluded:
“ (Essiac use in cancer has)…some weak evidence of its effectiveness.. the nature and quality of studies reporting benefit are such that the findings can only be regarded as preliminary.”
The U.S. National Cancer Institute (5) says:
“At this time, evidence does not support the use of either Essiac or Flor•Essence in the treatment of cancer patients…”
“Studies performed on the preparation of
Essiac in Canada and by the National Cancer Institute found that the product had no anti-tumor activity.”(9)
“Essiac… a fake cancer cure”(10)
1) E. Kaegi and Institute. Task Force on Alternative Therapies of the Canadian Breast Cancer Research
Unconventional therapies for cancer: 1. Essiac, Can. Med. Assoc. J., Apr 1998; 158: 897 – 9022)Cancer 2) Commission Reports, Record Group 10, Series 106, at the Archives of Ontario, Toronto
3) Essiac Product Monograph, CAMline. Accessed 03-04-09 : http://www.camline.ca/professionalreview/pr.php?NHPID=17
4) Essiac Canada International Website : http://essiacproducts.com/
5) US National Institute of Health, National Cancer Institute, Essiac – Flor-Essence PDQ summary : http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/pdq/cam/essiac/HealthProfessional/page1
6) Flora Health, Flor-Essence Herbal Tea Blend : http://www.florahealth.com/Flora/Home/canada/Products/R8070.asp
7)Richardson et al., Complementary/alternative medicine use in a comprehensive cancer center and the implications for oncology, J Clin Oncol. 2000 Jul;18(13):2505-14.
8) Use of complementary/alternative medicine by breast cancer survivors in Ontario: prevalence and perceptions. Boon H, Stewart M et al., J Clin Oncol. 2000 Jul;18(13):2515-21.
9) FDA, Drug Import Alert : http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/ImportAlerts/ora_import_ia6664.html
10) FDA, News release June 2008, FDA Warns Individuals and Firms to Stop Selling Fake Cancer ‘Cures’ : http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/2008/ucm116913.htm
AA) Seely D, Kennedy DA et al., In vitro analysis of the herbal compound Essiac.
Oncol Rep. 2004 Feb;11(2):471-6.
BB) Leonard SS. Et al, Essiac tea: scavenging of reactive oxygen species and effects on DNA damage, J Ethnopharmacol. 2006 Jan 16;103(2):288-96. Epub 2005 Oct 13.
CC) Ottenweller J, Putt K, Blumenthal EJ, et al.: Inhibition of prostate cancer-cell proliferation by Essiac. J Altern Complement Med 10 (4): 687-91, 2004
DD) Tai J.,et al. In vitro comparison of Essiac and Flor-Essence on human tumor cell lines., Oncol Rep. 2004 Feb;11(2):471-6.
EE) Hutchison, D.J., Experimental Chemotherapy, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, Rye, NY, personal communication, September 26, 1988 and March 1989
FF) OTA UCOOTA. Essiac. Unconventional cancer treatments. Washington, D.C.: US Congress Office of Technology Assistance (OTA). US Government Printing Office.; 1990 1990.
GG) Eberding A et al., Evaluation of the antiproliferative effects of Essiac on in vitro and in vivo models of prostate cancer compared to paclitaxel, Nutr Cancer. 2007;58(2):188-96.
HH) Kulp KS, et al., Essiac and Flor-Essence herbal tonics stimulate the in vitro growth of human breast cancer cells, Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2006 Aug;98(3):249-59. Epub 2006 Mar 16.
II)Karn H, Moore, M. The use of the herbal remedy ESSIAC in an outpatient cancer population. In: American Society of Clinical Oncology: Meeting Program Proceedings; 1997: American Society of Clinical Oncology; 1997.
JJ)Richardson M, Sanders, T, Tamayo, C, Perez, C, Plamer, JL. Flor Essence Herbal Tonic Use in North America: A profile of general consumers and cancer patients. Herbalgram 2000;50:40-46.
KK) Project OBCIE. A guide to unconventional cancer therapies. 1st ed. Toronto, ON: Ontario Breast Cancer Information Exchange Project; 1994
LL) Zick SM, Sen A, Feng Y, et al. Trial of Essiac to ascertain its effect in women with breast cancer (TEA-BC). J Altern Complement Med 2006 Dec;12(10):971-80.
MM) Geyer C, et al. Dose-schedule optimization the hexacyclic camptothecin (CPT) analog dx-8951f: a phase I and pharmacokinetic study with escalation of both treatment duration and dose (meeting abstract). Proc Annu Meet Am Soc Clin Oncol 1999;18.
NN) Oncolink, Abramson Cancer Center of the University of Pennsylvania, NCI/PDQ® Health professionals: Essiac/FlorEssence (PDQ®), accessed 04-05-09
00) Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, Essiac Healthcare Professional Monograph : accessed 04-05-09